ESOPs are now a routine part of Indian pay. EY’s Future of Pay 2026 report puts ESOP adoption at about 78% of companies in 2025, up from about 71% a year earlier.
So when an offer letter says “₹10 lakh in ESOPs”, what is that line really worth to you? And if you’re the founder writing it, what will it cost the company? The answer to both depends on the same handful of terms.
This article weighs ESOP benefits and drawbacks from both seats, using Indian data and a worked example with four possible outcomes. If your company runs its ESOPs on Hissa, you can check those terms against live numbers before you decide.
ESOP in India
Before weighing the pros and cons, it helps to agree on what an ESOP is, because search results mix up two different things.
An ESOP in India is an employee stock option plan. It lets you buy company shares at a fixed price once your options vest, moving from grant to vesting, then to exercise and finally a sale.
Some search results describe the American “Employee Stock Ownership Plan”, a retirement trust that holds shares for workers. That’s a different arrangement from the stock options Indian startups grant.
Suggested read: What is an ESOP in India?
What Are the ESOP Benefits for Employees?
For employees, the appeal of an ESOP comes down to sharing the value you help create. These four benefits matter most in practice.
1. A share in the company’s growth
You buy shares at the exercise price fixed in your grant letter, however much the company grows. If the share price rises from ₹100 to ₹500, each option carries ₹400 of gain before tax.
2. Liquidity events are becoming more common
Indian startups increasingly let employees sell before an IPO. Inc42 counts 12 startup buybacks in 2025 that paid more than 9,265 employees over ₹1,409 crore.
Some companies run them again and again. Urban Company had granted ESOPs to 1,593 current and former employees by May 2024, according to its investor relations page. Of those, 784 had sold ₹306 crore of shares across five programmes.
3. No tax until you act
There’s no tax when options are granted or when they vest. Tax arises only when you exercise, and employees of eligible DPIIT-recognised startups can defer it for a limited period, or until they leave or sell.
4. Pay that grows with tenure
Vesting rewards stay through the company’s growth years, and many companies add refresh grants for strong performers. Over time, that can add up to far more than an annual bonus.
What Are the Drawbacks of ESOPs for Employees?
The same features that make ESOPs attractive also carry risks. These are the ones employees run into most often.
- Paper value isn’t cash: Your options turn into money only when a buyer appears, whether in a buyback or at an exit.
- Tax before cash: Perquisite tax falls due when you exercise, often years before you can sell the shares.
- Deadlines on exit: Unvested options lapse when you leave, and vested ones lapse if the exercise window closes. In December 2025, Unacademy moved to cut former employees’ windows to 30 days from 10 years, then put the change on hold a month later.
- Dilution and preferences: New funding rounds shrink your percentage, and investors’ liquidation preferences can reduce what ordinary shares receive in a low exit.
- Uneven outcomes: Urban Company says its grants are skewed towards critical roles and high performers, so two employees can see very different results.
- Concentration: Your salary and your savings can both end up tied to one company.
None of these risks makes options worthless. They do mean the figure in an offer letter is a best case, and the real value depends on the company’s growth and the terms in your scheme.
Suggested read: ESOP liquidity in India
How Can the Same Grant Turn Out So Differently?
Numbers make the trade-off much clearer, so take an employee with 2,000 fully vested options at a ₹100 exercise price. The share price at exit decides everything, as the three outcomes below show.
- Strong exit at ₹500 a share: The gain is 2,000 × ₹400, which is ₹8 lakh before tax.
- Flat exit at ₹150 a share: The gain is 2,000 × ₹50, which is ₹1 lakh.
- Down round at ₹80 a share: The options are under water, so you simply don’t exercise and the gain is nil.
A fourth case shows the tax trap. Suppose you’d exercised early at a fair market value of ₹300. You paid ₹2 lakh for the shares and about ₹1.2 lakh in perquisite tax at a 30% slab.
Selling later at ₹80 a share brings in ₹1.6 lakh against ₹3.2 lakh paid out. That’s a shortfall of ₹1.6 lakh before any relief from the capital loss. The chart below puts all four outcomes side by side.
The lesson is to treat options as a possible upside, never as guaranteed pay. Exercise when you can see a route to selling, or when the tax is affordable even if the price falls.
Before you exercise, check the latest fair market value and the company’s buyback history. Then work out the cash you’d need if the shares stayed unsold for years.
What Are the Benefits of ESOPs for Founders?
From the founder’s seat, an ESOP is a tool for building a team before the company can pay market salaries. Here’s why so many startups use one.
- Hire on less cash: Equity tops up salaries a young company can’t match today, which helps it compete with larger employers.
- Retention through vesting: A standard four-year plan, with nothing vesting in the first year, rewards people who stay through the hardest stretch.
- Alignment: Employees whose wealth tracks the company’s value tend to think and act more like owners.
- Ownership as culture: Broad grants signal that the team shares in the outcome. Urban Company had awarded 11% of its fully diluted cap table as ESOPs by 2024.
These benefits show up only when employees understand their grants. A grant letter nobody can read, or a value nobody can check, earns little loyalty however generous it looks on paper.
Founders should also decide early who receives options. Broad grants and senior-only grants send very different signals to the team, and both are hard to reverse later.
Suggested read: ESOPs for startups in India
What Are the Drawbacks of ESOPs for Founders?
An ESOP also carries real costs for the company, and founders who plan for them early avoid most of the pain.
- Dilution: The option pool comes out of the founders’ and investors’ ownership, and every top-up shrinks it further.
- Accounting cost: Ind AS companies book the fair value of options as an employee expense while they vest, which lowers reported profit.
- Administration and compliance: Resolutions, registers and yearly valuations all need upkeep as the team grows.
- Liquidity expectations: Employees increasingly expect buybacks, which need company cash or willing investors.
- Trust risk: Changing terms for former employees can damage goodwill quickly, as Unacademy found.
None of these costs is a reason to skip an ESOP, but each one needs a budget line and an owner. Urban Company, for instance, had investors such as Vy Capital and Prosus buy the employee shares, which kept its liquidity promise without spending company cash.
Suggested read: What is Ind AS 102?
How Do ESOP Benefits and Drawbacks Compare?
The honest answer depends on the company’s terms and on your appetite for risk. The table below sums up the trade-off for each side.
| Side | Main benefits | Main drawbacks | What tips the balance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Employees | Share in growth, buyback cash, tax only on exercise | Illiquidity, tax before cash, exit deadlines | A fair strike, a long exit window and a record of buybacks |
| Founders | Hiring on less cash, retention, alignment | Dilution, accounting expense, administration | Clear terms, a liquidity plan and accurate records |
For a plan-by-plan test covering the strike price, the exercise window and the leaver terms, Hissa has a separate checklist.
Suggested read: A five-question test for your ESOP plan
How Do You Get More Out of an ESOP?
A few questions and design choices can tilt the balance your way, whichever side of the grant you’re on.
- Employees: Ask how the exercise price compares with fair market value and how long you have to exercise after leaving. Also ask about past buybacks and the fully diluted share count.
- Founders: Offer a longer exit window and state a liquidity plan. Write grant letters people can understand, and give employees a live view of their grants.
Run an ESOP Plan Your Whole Team Can Trust
The drawbacks above rarely come from the options themselves. They come from missing information, or missing cash, at the wrong moment, and that’s the part Hissa fixes.
Employees get a portal that shows each grant’s vesting and current value, with the perquisite tax worked out before they exercise. Founders and HR get one record for grants, vesting and exits, with vesting alerts that reach everyone on time. When people need cash before an IPO, Hissa Fund can buy their vested shares without touching the company’s balance sheet.
See it on your own cap table. Book a demo with Hissa and walk through your plan from grant to liquidity.
