A fund statement can show a 22% IRR beside a 1.3x TVPI, and both can be accurate while telling different stories. AIF investors encounter this puzzle in their statements, as do angel investors and ESOP holders valuing their own stakes.
The money measured this way is large. Indian AIFs had gathered commitments of ₹18.68 lakh crore by 30 September 2026, according to SEBI’s AIF statistics.
This guide covers IRR first, then MOIC and TVPI, and closes with a rupee example you can rebuild in a spreadsheet.
IRR meaning: What does internal rate of return measure?
IRR, or internal rate of return, is the yearly return an investment earns once you account for when each rupee went in and came out. In technical terms, it is the discount rate that brings the combined present value of every cash flow to zero.
Quick answer
IRR is the yearly compound rate that makes the money you invested and the money you received equal once both are discounted. Cash that comes back sooner pushes IRR higher.
Written as an equation, 0 = Σ CFₜ ÷ (1 + IRR)ᵗ, where CFₜ is the cash flow in year t. Money leaving your account counts as negative, while money returning counts as positive. A spreadsheet tests different rates until the sum reaches zero.
With one payment in and one out, IRR matches the annualized return, so ₹10 lakh growing to ₹12 lakh in a year gives 20%. The measure earns its place once cash moves on several irregular dates.
Analysts call IRR a money-weighted return because your own cash flows drive the answer. Mutual fund factsheets quote time-weighted returns that strip out investor flows, so the two can differ.
What do MOIC and TVPI measure?
MOIC and TVPI both express value as a multiple of the money put in, and they count that money differently. MOIC works at deal level, while TVPI measures a whole fund.
1. MOIC and the value of a single cheque
MOIC, the multiple on invested capital, divides realised value plus unrealised value by the capital invested. If you invest ₹1 crore in a Series A round and the stake is subsequently valued at ₹2.5 crore, your MOIC is 2.5x before any sale.
Managers usually quote gross MOIC, before management fees and carried interest, while LPs keep the lower net figure. On unlisted shares, the unrealised part rests on a valuation, often the latest round price. Liquidation preferences can also change what common shareholders receive at exit, so a paper MOIC and the final exit MOIC can differ.
Suggested read: How exit waterfalls and liquidation preferences work
2. TVPI and the capital a fund has called
TVPI, or total value to paid-in capital, divides a fund’s distributions plus the value of what it still owns by capital paid in. That denominator includes fees and fund expenses, so it exceeds invested capital.
Commitments differ from paid-in capital too. SEBI’s figures show ₹7.99 lakh crore actually raised against ₹18.68 lakh crore committed, and TVPI counts only money drawn.
When a fund has called all its capital and fees are negligible, TVPI and MOIC converge. In the ₹1 crore example, with no distributions and no fees, both read 2.5x.
The table below sets the three core metrics side by side.
| Metric | Formula | Accounts for timing? | Question it answers |
|---|---|---|---|
| IRR | Rate at which 0 = Σ CFₜ ÷ (1 + IRR)ᵗ | Yes, money-weighted | How fast has the money compounded each year? |
| MOIC | (Realised + unrealised value) ÷ invested capital | No | What has each rupee in this deal become? |
| TVPI | (Distributions + residual value) ÷ paid-in capital | No | What is the fund worth per rupee paid in? |
How do MOIC, TVPI and IRR differ in practice?
The three metrics differ in two ways: the denominator each uses and whether it accounts for time.
1. MOIC versus TVPI changes the denominator
Suppose LPs have paid ₹100 crore into a fund, of which ₹85 crore has gone into companies and ₹15 crore has covered fees and expenses. If the portfolio is now worth ₹136 crore, MOIC is 1.6x while TVPI is 1.36x.
For an LP, the lower TVPI provides a more complete picture, because fees are real money spent outside the portfolio. Fees weigh most while a fund is still investing, which holds TVPI below MOIC.
2. Multiples versus IRR adds the clock
A 2.5x multiple remains the same whether the investment is held for two years or twelve, while IRR changes sharply with the holding period. Returning 2.5x in one year works out to a 150% IRR, and spreading it over ten years brings IRR down to about 9.6%.
The effect also runs the other way. An early partial exit can lift a deal’s IRR while its final multiple stays modest, which is why LPs ask to see both numbers.
Which companion metrics do investors read alongside them?
Fund reports pair the core metrics with three additional measures that distinguish realized returns from unrealized value and compare performance against the stock market. The list below defines each one.
- DPI (distributions to paid-in capital): Cash returned to LPs divided by paid-in capital. A DPI above 1.0x means LPs have received more than they paid in.
- RVPI (residual value to paid-in capital): The current value of unsold holdings divided by paid-in capital. TVPI equals DPI plus RVPI.
- PME (public market equivalent): The fund’s cash flows replayed into a listed index such as the Nifty 50. It shows if private returns beat a public alternative.
DPI is the hardest number to flatter, since it counts only cash in hand. RVPI depends on how a manager marks unsold companies, usually at the last round or an independent valuer’s figure. Secondary sales let an investor turn RVPI into DPI before an IPO, since a buyer pays cash for shares previously valued only on paper.
Suggested read: What is an ESOP secondary fund?
Quick check
TVPI = DPI + RVPI, so a fund reporting 1.5x TVPI with 0.4x DPI has returned 40 paise in cash per rupee paid in. The other 1.1x depends on future exits.
How do Indian AIF benchmarks report these metrics?
Indian AIF returns are benchmarked according to vintage year. Crisil publishes pooled IRR for Category I and II funds beside the paid-in multiples and a PME+ comparison.
Crisil’s AIF benchmarks group schemes by the financial year of their first close, so FY17 funds are compared only with other FY17 funds. Returns are stated after fund expenses and before carried interest and tax, so an investor’s own result will be lower.
The table below takes three vintages from Crisil’s Category I benchmark in rupee terms, as on 30 September 2025.
| Vintage | Schemes | Pooled IRR | DPI | RVPI | TVPI |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| FY17 | 11 | 28.4% | 1.0x | 2.2x | 3.2x |
| FY20 | 17 | 18.0% | 0.1x | 1.7x | 1.8x |
| FY24 | 16 | 21.7% | 0.2x | 1.1x | 1.3x |
FY24 funds report a higher IRR than FY20 funds despite having a lower TVPI of 1.3x compared with 1.8x. A young fund’s IRR covers a short period, so one marked-up round inflates it.
FY17 shows what maturity looks like. Its 1.0x DPI means LPs have their capital back in cash, while most of its 3.2x TVPI depends on exits still ahead. Currency moves the figure as well, since the FY17 vintage returns 23.8% in US dollars against 28.4% in rupees, a lower result for foreign LPs.
What are the limitations of IRR, MOIC and TVPI?
IRR can be overstated by fund borrowing and its reinvestment assumption, while the multiples ignore time and lean on paper valuations. The list below takes each weakness in turn.
- Reinvestment assumption: IRR implicitly assumes interim cash is reinvested at the same rate. Modified IRR (MIRR) uses a more realistic reinvestment rate.
- Subscription lines: Short-term fund borrowing delays capital calls, so LP money appears invested for less time. IRR rises while the portfolio stays the same.
- Multiple solutions: Cash flows that switch signs more than once can produce two valid IRRs.
- Scale: A 60% IRR on a ₹5 lakh cheque adds less wealth than 18% on ₹1 crore. Position size must be evaluated separately.
- Paper marks: Unrealised value is only as reliable as the valuation behind it, which for unlisted shares may be months old.
Questions to put to a fund manager
Each weakness above becomes a question to ask before trusting a reported figure.
Are these returns gross or net of fees and carried interest?
What is the IRR with and without the subscription line?
How was each unsold company valued, and on what date?
Which vintage-year benchmark does the fund compare itself with?
How can you calculate IRR and TVPI for your own holdings?
You can check any reported IRR or TVPI, or build your own, with a dated list of cash flows and a spreadsheet. Angel investors and ESOP holders often have to calculate these figures themselves.
The five steps below work for a single stake or a whole portfolio.
- List each outflow by date: Enter every cheque or capital call, fees included, as a negative number. For an after-tax figure on ESOPs, add the perquisite tax paid at exercise.
- List each inflow by date: Enter distributions and sale proceeds, including buybacks and secondary sales, as positive numbers.
- Add today’s value last: Use the latest fair value of what you still hold, such as the most recent board-approved round price.
- Run XIRR: In Excel or Google Sheets, =XIRR(values, dates) handles irregular dates, as Microsoft’s XIRR guide describes.
- Divide for the multiples: Total inflows over total outflows give TVPI, and cash inflows alone give DPI.
Take an angel investor with one unlisted company, whose cash flows appear in the table below.
| Date | Event | Cash flow (₹ lakh) |
|---|---|---|
| 15 Apr 2021 | Seed investment | −25 |
| 10 Oct 2022 | Follow-on in a bridge round | −10 |
| 20 Mar 2025 | Partial sale in a secondary | +20 |
| 30 Sep 2026 | Remaining shares at the latest round price | +45 |
The investor has paid ₹35 lakh and holds ₹65 lakh of total value, a TVPI of 1.86x. Only ₹20 lakh of that is cash, which gives a DPI of 0.57x and an RVPI of 1.29x.
XIRR on these dates returns about 14.5%. Had the ₹20 lakh sale happened on 30 September 2026, the multiple would stay at 1.86x while IRR would fall to about 13.0%.
An angel weighing an early partial sale should therefore look at both measures before deciding. Selling sooner can increase IRR and DPI, while holding the investment preserves exposure to future valuation changes.
Suggested read: How to calculate ESOP value
How can Hissa help you track returns on unlisted holdings?
Spreadsheets get harder to keep current with every new cheque and funding round. The tools below show how Hissa replaces them.
- Portfolio management: Every private investment is held in one dashboard, with MOIC and IRR calculated for each holding and for the whole portfolio.
- Exit modelling: Investors can compare MOIC and IRR under different exit values before deciding to hold or sell.
- Hissa fund: A SEBI-registered Category II AIF with a $35M corpus. It gives employees cash for vested ESOP shares, with T+5 settlement and no IPO required.
Whatever tool holds the numbers, IRR shows how fast money compounded, while MOIC and TVPI show how much value each rupee created. Read them beside DPI and RVPI to separate cash from paper, and compare funds only within the same vintage year.
Maintaining a dated record of your cash flows allows you to verify reported returns more efficiently. To see MOIC and IRR calculated across your unlisted holdings, book a demo with Hissa.
